MetroWest Chess Club - Spring Swiss
April   2, 9, 16, 23, 30 & May 7   2002

Standings       Wall Chart       Pairings       Commentary        USCF X-table       Archive        Home
Tournament Commentary
Tuesday, March 25, 2003    12:57 PM
written by Larry Eldridge
 

Commentary will usually be posted to this page late Wednesday or Thursday night.

Surprise! After falling by the wayside for two months, your correspondent has a sudden urge to write about the March tournament(!?).  We'll start with the most recent event, though -- Round One of the big April-May Spring Swiss.  Then for anyone who wants to catch up on earlier action, here are links to the first three tournaments of 2002:

January:     Chamberlain defeats Curdo, wins tournament
February:    Foygel sweeps Open section; Keskar scores spectacular string of upsets
March:        Foygel, Curdo, and Eldridge share top honors

This months Round 1 commentary is shown below.

Round 6 - May 7, 2002

Thirteen-year-old Niki Konovalchuk was sensation of the annual Spring Open, going undefeated throughout the six-round tournament, upsetting master Frank Sisto in the last round, and finishing in a four-way tie for first place with Igor Foygel, John Curdo, and Robert Powell.  Powell also outperformed his rating in a steady march to 4.5 points and a share of the top spot, while Foygel and Curdo gave us a new word in the chess lexicon: the "grandmaster bye"!

Konovalchuk, rated 1765 and seeded near the bottom of the 29-player Open Section, achieved a mild upset by drawing Powell (1951) in Round One, then also drew with Eric Ogren (1787). The Natick youngster moved into contention with successive victories over A-players Paul Mishkin and Jack Martin, remained among the leaders via a half-point bye in Round 5, then pulled off his shocker against Sisto (2249).

Powell, the only player in the victorious quartet to play every round, started off with three straight draws, then won three in a row, capping his drive with a last-round decision over expert John Chamberlain.

Meanwhile Foygel and Curdo, via a pair of strategic byes apiece, managed to play the entire tournament without facing each other. Each drew with Sisto and won the other three games he played -- all against A and B players.

This "dance" could easily have backfired, as Sisto went into the last round with a chance to win the tournament clear -- a result which certainly seemed likely considering that he had the white pieces against a player rated nearly 500 points below him. Young Konovalchuk upset the apple cart, though, so Foygel, Curdo, and Powell all got a lucky share of top honors.  It was a good tournament but a tough finish for Sisto, the well known Waltham master and chess writer who was making his first appearance at the MCC.  He played all six rounds and faced by far the toughest competition of anyone in the field (he was the only one to meet both Foygel and Curdo), only to lose out via that last-round upset.  His final score of 4 points put him in a three-way tie with Martin and Robert Harvey for fifth place.  The 20-player U1750 section developed into a three-way dogfight among eventual winner Na Ruthramoorthy, runner-up Mark Kaprielian, and Jim Todhunter, who wound up tying for third place with George Goulding and Bill Stein. It was the aforementioned trio, however, who took turns beating each other over the last half of the tournament to create the exciting finish.

Ruthramoorthy took the halfway lead with a perfect 3-0 score, but then lost in Round 4 to Todhunter, who promptly lost in Round 5 to Kaprielian.  Kappy was now the clear leader, but Ruthramoorthy won their decisive last-round game to leapfrog past him and take clear first place.  Goulding and Stein were also in it most of the way, but both lost to Ruthramoorthy and dropped a couple of half-points as well to miss out on the top placing.

Chris Gagnepain emerged as the clear winner in the U1450 section with an undefeated 5 points (4 wins, 2 draws), followed by James Klinkenberg, Al Schaefer, Lomer Cormier, and Tom Powers with 4.5 each.  Gagnepain and Powers, with four each plus a draw in their earlier head-to-head battle, were the co-leaders entering the last round.  Gagnepain drew with Cormier, but Powers lost his chance to win or share the top spot via a loss to Schaefer.  Klinkenberg, meanwhile, pulled into a share of second place via a last-round win over John Sheehan.  This section attracted 29 players, making the total for the tournament an impressive 78.

As for upsets, while Konovalchuk’s 484-pointer over Sisto was clearly the most significant, it wasn’t the biggest one in the tournament. That honor went to Sam Giler(809) via a 539-point first-round shocker over Jim Krycka (1348).  The only other form reversal of "monster" proportions was Daniel Newman (1604) over John Chamberlain (2017), also early in the tournament.  Giler later had another significant upset (293 points) over Justin Grimes (1102), while Newman also had a second, though smaller form reversal over Mike Barry (1753). Another double-upsetter was Severine Wamala (1598) over both Larry Eldridge (1751) and Jeff Penta (1860).  Others of note: Sisto’s draw with Foygel(2566); Greg Siciliano (1421) over Tim Vaughan (1584); Harvey Reed (1169) over Krycka (1348), Gagnepain (129)over Sheehan (1435), and Michael Kaye (1057) over Jeff Gibson (1284).

MCC Spring Swiss: Open -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Niki Konovalchuk (1765) 484.0	Frank M Sisto (2249)
Severine Wamala (1598) 	262.0	Jeff Georg Penta (1860)
Daniel B Newman (1604) 	149.0	Michael Barry (1753)
Robert W Powell (1951) 	66.0	John Chamberlain (2017)
Himanshu Keskar (1765) 	21.0	Stephen E Smith (1786)
Larry Eldridge (1751) 	21.0	William Michael (1793)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1750 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Matthew W Phelps (1499) 62.5	Walter Champion (1624)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1450 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Sam A Giler (809) 	293.0	Justin P Grimes (1102)
Harvey G Reed (1169) 	98.0	Fred L Harvey (1267)
David L Levens (1090) 	90.5	Clark R Ewer (1271)
Chris Gagnepain (1306) 	34.5	Lomer J Cormier (1375)
Jame Klinkenberg (1421) 14.0	John D Sheehan (1435)

Round 5 - April 30, 2002
MCC Spring Swiss: Open -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Severine Wamala (1598) 	153.0	Larry Eldridge (1751)
Himanshu Keskar (1765) 	47.5	Jeff Georg Penta (1860)
Neil B Cousin (1828) 	34.0	Mark L Fins (1862)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1750 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Gregor Siciliano (1421) 163.0	Timothy Vaughan (1584)
Menno G Koning (1500) 	81.0	Gatumba Z Abu (1581)
Mark Kaprielian (1654) 	60.0	James Todhunter (1714)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1450 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Harvey G Reed (1169) 	179.0	James A Krycka (1348)
Chris Gagnepain (1306) 	129.0	John D Sheehan (1435)
Michael W Kaye (1057) 	113.5	Jeffry R Gibson (1284)
Thomas E Powers (1345) 	76.0	Jame Klinkenberg (1421)


Round 4 - April 23, 2002
MCC Spring Swiss: Open -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Frank M Sisto (2249) 	158.5	Igor Foygel (2566)
Niki Konovalchuk (1765) 73.0	John W Martin (1838)
Jacob Perkowski (1728)  58.0	Matthew Rothman (1786)
Michael Barry (1753) 	53.5	Jeff Georg Penta (1860)
Stephen E Smith (1786) 	31.0	Paul A Mishkin (1848)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1750 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
John Stengrevics (1505) 76.0	Gatumba Z Abu (1581)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1450 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Clark R Ewer (1271) 	58.0	Douglas Thompson (1387)
Chris Gagnepain (1306) 	19.5	Thomas E Powers (1345)
Round 3 - April 16, 2002
A four-way tie for first place at the midway point sets up some exciting Open section action in the final three rounds.

Top-seeded Igor Foygel took a third-round bye after winning his first two games, and three other players seized the opportunity to grab a share of the lead. No. 2 Frank Sisto, who also had gone 2-0, battled to a draw with John Curdo on Board one, while Jared Becker and Trev De Koekkoek each won to catch the leaders.

Curdo, who had taken a bye the previous week, heads a group of seven players still in the hunt at 2.0, just a half-point off the pace.

Na Ruthramoorthy turned back surprising newcomer Joey Kagan on Board One in the U1750 section to emerge with the only perfect 3-0 score. Jim Todhunter, Mark Fins, Mark Kaprielian, and George Goulding share the runner-up spot at 2.5.

Tom Powers, Chris Gagnepain, and Fred Harvey rolled on in the U1450 section, each winning his third straight game. James Klinkenberg is next with two wins and a bye for 2.5.

Upsets were much rarer than in previous rounds, with no really big ones, and only four qualifying under our 100-point criterion. Himanshu Keskar (1765) defeated Joe Kelly (1879) in the Open section; Ethan Thompson (1467) stopped Tim Vaughan (1584) in the U1750, and Chris smith (1152) knocked off Jim Krycka (1348) while Harvey surprised Carl Phillips (1434) in the U1450 group.

Two more players jumped in, raising the total entries to 76.

 
MCC Spring Open: Open -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Himanshu Keskar (1765) 114.0	Joseph F Kelly (1879)
Ames Abbot (1783) 	84.0	Robert W Powell (1951)
Niki Konovalchuk (1765) 83.0	Paul A Mishkin (1848)
Matthew Rothman (1786) 	74.0	Jeff Georg Penta (1860)
Trev De Koekkoek (1942) 71.0	Edward R Epp (2013)
Stephen E Smith (1786) 	23.0	Robert L Harvey (1832)
John A Curdo (2224) 	12.5	Frank M Sisto (2249)
MCC Spring Open: U1750 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Ethan Thompson (1467) 	117.0	Timothy Vaughan (1584)
Matthew W Phelps (1499) 99.0	Severine Wamala (1598)

MCC Spring Open: U1450 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Christophe Smith (1152) 196.0	James A Krycka (1348)
Fred L Harvey (1267) 	167.0	Carl W Phillips (1434)
Chris Gagnepain (1306) 	55.0	Robert E King (1361)
Thomas E Powers (1345) 	30.0	Lomer J Cormier (1375)

  
  
  
Round 2 - April 9, 2002
Exciting battles are developing in all three sections approaching the halfway point of the six-round tournament. Meanwhile, seven players jumped in for Round 2, boosting the total field to an eye-catching 74.

Top-seeded Igor Foygel and No. 2 Frank Sisto are the only players with perfect scores after two rounds in the 27-player Open section.  Foygel opted for a bye in Round 3, however, so Sisto meets No. 3 seed John Curdo (1.5) on Board One.  A half dozen other players are tied with Curdo and will pair off on the next few boards to jockey for top positions.

Navan Ruthramoorthy, Mark Kaprielian, and newcomer Joey Kagan all won their second straight games in the 21-player U1750 section for a three-way tie at the top.  Jim Todhunter, George Goulding, and Gatumba Abu are breathing down their necks with 1.5 points apiece. 

The 26-player U1450 section has a five-way logjam at 2.0 among Lomer Cormier, Robert King, Tom Powers, Chris Gagnepain, and Fred Harvey.

Upsets were scarce in Round 2, but there was one biggie as Dan Newman(1604) continued his "giant-killing" role of the previous two months by defeating expert John Chamberlain. The only other form reversal in any section meeting our 100-point criterion was Fred Harvey (1267) over Douglas Thompson (1387).

 
MCC Spring Open: Open -- Upsets
Name			Pnts	Victim
Daniel B Newman (1604)	413.0	John Chamberlain (2017)
Matthew Rothman (1786)	 82.5	Robert W Powell (1951)
Jacob Perkowski (1728)	 67.0	Mark L Fins (1862)
Himanshu Keskar (1765)	 33.5	Robert L Harvey (1832)
Ames Abbot (1783)	 27.5	John W Martin (1838)
Neil B Cousin (1828)	 25.5	Joseph F Kelly (1879)
Niki Konovalchuk (1765)	 11.0	Eric Ogren (1787)
MCC Spring Open: U1750 -- Upsets
Name			Pnts	Victim
Ethan Thompson (1467)	 47.5	Robert J Oresick (1562)
Gatumba Z Abu (1581)	 32.5	George Goulding (1646)
MCC Spring Open: U1450 -- Upsets
Name			Pnts	Victim
Fred L Harvey (1267)	120.0	Douglas Thompson (1387)
Chris Gagnepain (1306)	 94.0	Alan D Schaefer (1400)
Round 1 - April 2, 2002

A total of 67 players entered the tournament -- already more than last year's 65, and virtually certain to go over the magic 70 figure via "jump-ins" in later rounds.  Among the new entries the club welcomes Master Frank Sisto in his first MCC appearance.  He joins regulars Igor Foygel and John Curdo at the top of the wall chart, and all three were among the nine competitors starting off on the right foot in the 23-player Open Section.

Other first-round winners in rating order were favorites Ed Epp, Trevor De Koekkoek, and Mark Fins along with upset victors Al Ward (over John Chamberlain), Larry Eldridge (over Jason Spector), and Jacob Perkowski (over Joe Kelly).  One notable "non-upsetter" was Himanshu Keskar, who has gained more than 300 rating points via a sensational string of surprise victories, but who fell this time to Fins.

There were also nine first-round winners in the 20-player U1750 section: Jim Todhunter, Na Ruthramoorthy, Mark Kaprielian, George Goulding, Philip Mercurio, William F Stein, Severine Wamala, Gatumba Abu, and Joey Kagan. 

The U1450 section drew the biggest field (24) and had all decisive games, thus producing a dozen first-round victors: Carl Phillips, James Klinkenberg, Al Schaefer, Douglas Thompson, Lomer Cormier, Robert E King, Tom Powers, Chris Gagnepain, Fred Harvey, Harvey Reed , Sam Giler, and George Kilmain.

This section also produced the round's two biggest upsets: Giler (809) over Jim Krycka (1348) for a whopping 539-point differential, and Harvey Reed (1169) over John Sheehan (1435).  The only other upset meeting our 100-point criterion was Eric Ogren (1787) drawing Jared Becker (1994).


MCC Spring Swiss: Open -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Alfred G Ward (1800) 	217.0	John Chamberlain (2017)
Larry Eldridge (1751) 	182.0	Jason St Spector (1933)
Jacob Perkowski (1728) 	151.0	Joseph F Kelly (1879)
Eric Ogren (1787) 	103.5	Jared Becker (1994)
Niki Konovalchuk (1765) 93.0	Robert W Powell (1951)
MCC Spring Swiss: U1750 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Ethan Thompson (1467) 	78.5	Walter Champion (1624)

MCC Spring Swiss: U1450 -- Upsets
Name 			Pnts 	Victim
Sam A Giler (809) 	539.0	James A Krycka (1348)
Harvey G Reed (1169) 	266.0	John D Sheehan (1435)