MetroWest Chess Club - Summer Time Swiss
June   4, 11, 18, 25    2002

Standings       Wall Chart       Pairings       Commentary        USCF X-table       Archive        Home
Tournament Commentary
Tuesday, March 25, 2003    12:58 PM
written by Larry Eldridge
 

Round 4 - June 25, 2002

Precocious schoolboy Noah Pang emerged as the clear winner of the June tournament with 3.5 points, followed by a quartet of Frank Sisto, John Curdo, Ed Epp, and Daniel Newman a half-point behind.

Pang, who just completed seventh grade, was the only player to win his first three games, then took a half-point bye in the last round which assured him of at least a tie for first place. Sisto, Curdo, and Epp all had a chance to catch him in the final session, but the former took a bye, while Curdo and Epp battled to a draw. Newman, meanwhile, defeated young expert Max Enkin in his final test to join the runner-up group at 3.0.

The U1700 section was sort of like the World Cup -- a bunch of surprising results by newcomers in the early rounds only to have the traditional contenders prevail in the end. Regulars William Stein and Matthew Phelps were the last-round winners on the top two boards, defeating relative newcomers Nicholas D'Alessandro and Joey Kagan, respectively, to share first place with 3.5 points apiece.

The top-rated Stein’s victory over D'Alessandro on Board One ended the latter’s amazing string of successes in his first three USCF tournaments. D'Alessandro drew his first rated game, then won seven in a row (including three straight in this tournament) before finally succumbing..

Kagan, a high school student, also had staged a series of major upsets to reach top contention entering the last round. But he, too, finally met his match.

Despite their losses, both D'Alessandro and Kagan played far above expectations for the tournament as a whole, and gained significantly in the rating department. D'Alessandro finished tied for third place with George Goulding at 3.0, but Kagan’s loss, as frequently happens in these last-round match-ups, knocked him out of the money with a final 2.5 tally.

Clark Ewer and Douglas Thompson both rolled to 3-0 scores in the U1400 section, then Ewer won their decisive Board One match-up for a 4-0 sweep: the only perfect score in the tournament. Jeffry Gibson also was perfect after three rounds, but took a half-point bye in the finale to finish at 3.5, while Calvin Hori, who had taken a bye earlier, won his final game to match that result.

The bottom section also produced the biggest upset of the round --and indeed of the entire tournament: a 384-pointer scored by David Levens (987) over John McLaughlin (1371). The other major form reversal in the final round -- at least according to the ratings -- was Newman’s victory over Enkin despite a difference of 287 points 1769-2056. This may not really have been as big an upset as the numbers suggest, however, since Newman is clearly stronger than his current rating, which has been rising rapidly via a series of impressive  performances against higher-rated foes.

But the most significant upsets in terms of the battles for top honors, of course, were  Epp’s draw against Curdo, who out rated him by 201 points (2201-2000), and Ewer’s climactic victory over Thompson despite a 102-point differential (12563-1355).

Other last-round form reversals: Howard Goldowsky (1696) over Ed Astrachan (1868); Tom Powers (1300) over Walter Champion (1663); and Paul Tillotson (1506) over Mark Kaprielian (1638).

The fields totaled 23-19-26, respectively, for a total of 68 entries.
 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Daniel B Newman (1769) 	287.0 	Max Enkin (2056) 
Howard Goldowsky (1696) 172.0 	Edward Astrachan (1868) 
Edward R Epp (2000) 	100.5 	John A Curdo (2201) 
Alfred G Ward (1800) 	 56.0 	Larry Eldridge (1856) 
Robert W Powell (1915) 	 40.5 	John Chamberlain (1996) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Thomas E Powers (1300) 	181.5 	Walter Champion (1663) 
Paul M Tillotson (1506) 132.0 	Mark Kaprielian (1638) 
Gregor Siciliano (1412)  78.0 	Ethan Thompson (1490) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
David L Levens (987) 	384.0 	John Mc Laughlin (1371) 
Clark R Ewer (1253) 	102.0 	Douglas Thompson (1355) 
Mar Leeuwenburgh (1276)   6.0 	Ilya Abugov (1282)

Round 3 - June 18, 2002

Noah Pang defeated Dan Newman for his third straight victory to clinch at least a tie for first place with one round to go.  The precocious middle school student has the only perfect score heading into the last round, but he’s taking a half-point bye in that session and thus is "in the clubhouse" with a final score of 3.5.  This leaves the door open for masters Frank Sisto and John Curdo and expert Ed Epp, any of whom could tie him with a last-round win.

Curdo, who was held to a draw in the first round, and Sisto, who skipped the opening round and jumped in with a half-point bye, both climbed up through the "back door" with wins in the next two rounds. Epp, meanwhile, won his first two games and took a bye in Round 3, leaving them all tied for second place with 2.5 points each.

The last-round pairings pit the two masters against each other on Board One, with Sisto getting the white pieces. He also holds a rating edge over Curdo (2249 to 2201), thus continuing this tournament’s unusual trend of having a different player holding down the top board in every round: Curdo, Epp, Pang, and now Sisto.

Epp has white against Robert Powell, the highest-rated player with two points, on Board 2.

So the upshot is that there are a half-dozen possible outcomes. Pang could win it all if there are draws on the first two boards. If Board One is a draw and Epp wins, he will tie Pang for top honors. If Epp draws and Board One is a decisive game, the winner there will be the co-champion. Finally, if Epp wins and Board One is decisive, it will be a three-way tie among Pang, Epp, and either Sisto or Curdo.

Sensational newcomer Nicholas D'Alessandro stretched his winning streak to seven games to lead the U1700 section with the only perfect score.  D'Alessandro played the last two rounds of the Spring Open, obtaining a draw and a win; he tied for first place in the Short Time Swiss in May with a 3-0 result, and he is now 3-0 again heading into the last round here.  Also raising eyebrows in this section has been high school student Joey Kagan, who has staged a succession of major upsets to score 2.5 points and stand tied for second place with top-seeded Bill Stein and Matthew Phelps. D'Alessandro gets white against Stein while Phelps has white vs. Kagan in the top two match-ups.

Kagan is also a relative newcomer to the club and to USCF play. He made his debut in March, entering the bottom section and scoring 3 points to earn prize money. He moved up to the middle section for the April-May spring open and went 3-3. This month, starting with an official current rating of 1317, he has defeated Paul Tillotson (1506), drawn No. 2 seed Walter Champion (1663), and then upset Mark Kaprielian (1638).

The U1400 section features a three-way tie among Douglas Thompson, Jeffry Gibson, and Clark Ewer heading into the final round, all with perfect scores. Gibson is taking a half-point bye, so it’s Ewer-Thompson on Board One, with Calvin Hori (the only 2.5) meeting Lomer Cormier (2) on Board 2.

Upsets in Round 3 in addition to Kagan’s stunner over Kaprielian were Henry Forber-Pratt (948) over John Harvey (1277) in the bottom section, Phelps (1467) over Champion (1663) and Tom Powers (1300) over Ethan Thompson (1490) in the middle group, and Howard Goldowsky (1696) over Himanshu Keskar (1807) in the Open Section.

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Howard Goldowsky (1696) 111.0 	Himanshu Keskar (1807) 
Robert L Harvey (1886) 	 85.0 	Max Enkin (2056) 
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Joey Kagan (1317) 	321.0 	Mark Kaprielian (1638) 
Matthew W Phelps (1467) 196.0 	Walter Champion (1663) 
Thomas E Powers (1300) 	190.0 	Ethan Thompson (1490) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Hen Forber-Pratt (948) 	329.0 	John M Harvey (1277) 
Jeffry R Gibson (1284  ) 95.0 	Lomer J Cormier (1379) 

Round 2 - June 11, 2002
"Uneasy lies the head that wears a crown." The words are Henry IV’s, but they perfectly describe this month’s wild and wooly Open Section, where a different player will have held down Board One in each of the first three weeks.

John Curdo had the honor initially, but was held to a draw in the opening round. That put Ed Epp on top, and he kept his share of the lead with a second straight victory, but now has to relinquish Board One because he is taking a bye in Round 3. Noah Pang and Daniel Newman joined Epp as the halfway leaders with 2-0 scores, so they’ll meet in Round 3 with the higher-rated Pang now holding down the No. 1 spot. Curdo, Frank Sisto, John Chamberlain, and Na Ruthramoorthy are in a four-way deadlock a half-point back, and will battle among themselves in hopes of staying within striking distance.

George Goulding and Nick D’Alessandro share the lead with perfect scores in the U1700 section, followed by a half dozen competitors at 1.5.

Five players remain perfect in the U1400 group: Lomer Cormier, Douglas Thompson, Jeffry Gibson, Mark Leeuwenburgh, and Clark Ewer.

Joey Kagan (1317) held Walter Champion (1663) to a draw for the biggest upset of the round. Others: Simon Slutsky (1376) over John Stengrevics (1523); Newman (1769) over Powell (1915); Doug Hull (929) drawing Harvey Reed (1172) and Clark Ewer (1253) over John Mc Laughlin (1371).

A total of 11 players jumped in for Round 2, boosting the field to 22-19-25 = 66.

 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Daniel B Newman (1769) 	146.0 	Robert W Powell (1915) 
Neil B Cousin (1843) 	106.5 	Max Enkin (2056) 
Howard Goldowsky (1696)  63.5 	W Bradley Ryan (1823) 
Na Ruthramoorthy (1737)  63.0 	Alfred G Ward (1800) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Joey Kagan (1317) 	173.0 	Walter Champion (1663) 
Simon A Slutsky (1376) 	147.0 	John Stengrevics (1523) 
Gregor Siciliano (1412)  88.0 	Menno G Koning (1500) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Doug Hull (929) 	121.5 	Harvey G Reed (1172) 
Clark R Ewer (1253) 	118.0 	John Mc Laughlin (1371) 

Round 1 - June 4, 2002
An exciting first round left seven players tied for the Open Section lead and six others, including top-seeded John Curdo, a half-point back.

With perennial winner Igor Foygel sitting this tournament out and Curdo held to a draw by Neil Cousin, the first round "leader board" looks a bit different than usual. Ed Epp, Noah Pang, Robert Powell, Joe Kelly, Larry Eldridge, and David Newman won their initial tests to grab a share of the early lead, while Robert Frederick joined them at the top via a full-point bye as the paired-out player in the field of 19. The half-point group consists of Curdo, John Chamberlain, Ed Astrachan, Cousin, Mike Barry, and Na Ruthramoorthy.

Epp now takes over Board One and is paired against Eldridge. The other top boards are Kelly-Pang, Newman-Powell, and Frederick-Curdo.

Both other sections also had odd numbers of players and thus also had an extra player joining the top group via a full-point bye.

The 15-player U1700 section has a seven-way tie for the lead among Bill Stein, Walter Champion, George Goulding, Robert Oresick, Joey Kagan, Tom Powers (via the bye), and Nicholas D’Alessandro.

The 21-player U1400 section had all decisive games and thus 11 players sharing the lead: Lomer Cormier, John Mc Laughlin, Douglas Thompson, Jeffry Gibson, Mark Leeuwenburgh, Fred Harvey, Clark Ewer, Jenshiang Hong, Travis Nilsson (via the bye), Calvin Hori, and George Kilmain.

The top upset of the opening round was Kagan (1317) defeating Paul Tillotson (1506) in the middle section. Another form reversal in this group was Simon Slutsky (1376) drawing Mark Kaprielian (1638). The 1843-rated Cousin’s draw with the black pieces vs. Curdo (2201) was the top shocker in the Open Section, followed by Newman (1769) defeating Robert Harvey (1886) and Barry (1783) drawing Chamberlain (1996). There were no upsets meeting our 100-point criterion in the bottom section.

 
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Neil B Cousin (1843) 	179.0 	John A Curdo (2201) 
Daniel B Newman (1769) 	117.0 	Robert L Harvey (1886) 
Michael Barry (1783) 	106.5 	John Chamberlain (1996) 
Na Ruthramoorthy (1737)  65.5 	Edward Astrachan (1868) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Joey Kagan (1317) 	189.0 	Paul M Tillotson (1506) 
Simon A Slutsky (1376) 	131.0 	Mark Kaprielian (1638) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
		None