MetroWest Chess Club - Late Summer Swiss
August   6, 13, 20, 27,   2002

Standings       Wall Chart       Pairings       Commentary        USCF X-table       Archive        Home
Tournament Commentary
Tuesday, March 25, 2003    12:59 PM
written by Larry Eldridge
 

Round 4 - August 27, 2002

John Curdo and Trevor De Koekkoek shared first place in the August tournament with 3.5 points apiece.  Curdo rolled to three straight victories, then held the draw with the black pieces against top-seeded Igor Foygel in the last round to earn his share of the prize.

Foygel had been held to a draw by John Chamberlain in Round 3, so needed to win to leapfrog past Curdo for the top spot.  He gave it his all, but Curdo held on for the half-point that secured his place at the top.

De Koekkoek took a half-point bye in Round 2 and thus came from behind in "Swiss Gambit" fashion without having to face either Foygel or Curdo.  He still trailed the leader by a half point going into the last round, but he did upset Chamberlain there to earn his share of the top spot.

Foygel, Ed Epp, Neil Cousin, and schoolboy whiz Steve Chen finished in a four-way tie for third place at 3.0 apiece.

Jim Todhunter won the U1750 section outright with 3.5 points (a first-round bye, then three straight wins).  Walter Champion, Bill Stein, Mark Kaprielian, and Lomer Cormier tied for runner-up honors at 3.0.

Carl Phillips won the U1400 section clear, also with 3.5 points.  Tom Powers, Yuan Cao, and fifth-grader Calvin Bohn shared second place at 3.0.  Young Bohn had a sensational tournament, winning three straight games before having to skip the last round as he and his family were on vacation.  He was the clear tournament leader at this point, and thus would have clinched at least a share of first place with the half-point bye he would normally have been entitled to. Under the club’s new rules, however, last-round byes must now be requested before the start of Round 2, in order to qualify for the half-point, and alas, Calvin had neglected to do this and had to take a zero-point bye for his unplayed game.

Curdo’s draw with Foygel despite a 323-point rating difference was clearly the most important upset.  Others: Neil Cousin (1833) defeated Jason Spector (1956); Cormier (1328) defeated Ethan Thompson (1499), and Richard Albee (955) defeated Justin Grimes (1064).
 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
John A Curdo (2217) 	161.5 	Igor Foygel (2540) 
Neil B Cousin (1833) 	123.0 	Jason St Spector (1956) 
Larry Eldridge (1806) 	 93.0 	Robert L Harvey (1899) 
Trev De Koekkoek (1914)  80.0 	John Chamberlain (1994) 
Steve Chen (1760) 	 64.0 	Larry Pratt (1824) 
Ames Abbot (1773) 	 38.0 	Seneca L Nowland (1811) 
Alfred G Ward (1800) 	 10.0 	Daniel B Newman (1820) 

Name Pnts Victim 
Lomer J Cormier (1328) 	171.0 	Ethan Thompson (1499) 
Fred L Harvey (1298) 	 88.0 	Douglas Thompson (1386) 

Name Pnts Victim 
Richard Albee (955)  	109.0 	Justin P Grimes (1064) 
Harvey G Reed (1291) 	  7.0 	Ilya Abugov (1298) 
Round 3 - August 20, 2002
John Chamberlain (1994) held top-seeded Igor Foygel (2540) to a draw in an exciting Q vs. two Rs battle in Round 3, while No. 2 John Curdo defeated Ed Epp to take over the lead with the only perfect 3.0 score. Foygel, Chamberlain, and Trevor De Koekkoek, who defeated Bill Michael, are tied for second place at 2.5 each.

These results setup a dramatic last-round pairing on Board one: Curdo, who can win the tournament outright with a victory and needs a draw to clinch at least a tie for first place, has the black pieces against Foygel.  The latter, of course, is in a must-win position if he hopes to gain top honors. Meanwhile, it’s De Koekkoek-Chamberlain on Board 2, each hoping to win that game and have a chance for a share of first place himself.

Mark Kaprielian rolled to his third straight victory to take the lead in the U1750 section, while Jim Todhunter also won to take over clear second place with 2.5.  They’ll meet in a decisive Round 4 match up, with Kaprielian getting the white pieces.

Ten-year-old Calvin Bohn, having a sensational tournament, also won his third game in a row to emerge as the U1400 leader with the lone perfect score. The youngster is away on vacation for Round 4, and would thus have clinched at least a first-place tie -- and a chance for clear top honors -- with the usual half-point bye. Unfortunately, however, he failed to put in his request in time, so under the just-revised rules he gets zero points, thus finishing with only that 3.0 total.

This opens the door for Tom Powers and Carl Phillips, who are tied for second place at 2.5 after winning two games each and drawing their head-to-head contest.  Either or both of them can leapfrog past Bohn into first place with a victory in Round 4, while still in contention for a share of a potential multiple first-place tie are John McLaughlin, Jenshiang Hong, Philip Reed, and Yuan Cao, each with 2 points..

The last-round pairings are Powers-McLaughlin, Hong-Phillips, and Cao-Reed.

Chamberlain’s draw with Foygel was the most significant upset in Round 3, but even bigger in terms of point differential was Philip Reed (1009) defeating Harvey Reed (1291) in the bottom section.  Schoolboy Steve Chen (1690) continued his impressive string of upsets by beating Robert Harvey (1899), while others meeting our 100-point criterion were Lomer cormier (1328) drawing Bill Stein (1663) and Stephen Savage (1400) getting the half-point vs. George Goulding (1631).

The entries section-by-section are 26-23-15 for a total of 64 players.


Name                                 Pnts     Victim
John Chamberlain (1994)     273.0     Igor Foygel (2540)
Steve Chen (1760)              139.0     Robert L Harvey (1899)

Name                                 Pnts     Victim
Lomer J Cormier (1328)       167.5     William F Stein (1663)
Stephen W Savage (1400)    115.5     George Goulding (1631)
Matthew W Phelps (1505)      82.0     Herbert Weisberg (1587)

Name                                 Pnts     Victim
Philip J Reed (1009)           282.0     Harvey G Reed (1291)
Carl W Phillips (1365)            2.0     Thomas E Powers (1369)
 
Round 2 - August 13, 2002
Things went strictly according to form in the first half of this month’s tournament, with the top four seeds -- Igor Foygel, John Curdo, Ed Epp, and John Chamberlain -- all winning their first two games to share the Open Section lead. Trevor De Koekkoek, Rob Huntington, and Bill Michael are right on their heels at 1.5 apiece.

Ninth-grader-to-be Greg Siciliano has pulled two straight upsets to share top honors with Mark Kaprielian and Ethan Thompson in the U1750 section, while upcoming fifth-grader Calvin Bohn has gone 2-0 in the U1400 section to tie with Tom Powers and Carl Phillips for the halfway lead in that group.

The result of all this is a bunch of key third-round pairings: Chamberlain-Foygel and Curdo-Epp in the top section; Thompson-Kaprielian and Jim Todhunter (1.5) - Siciliano in the middle group; and Phillips-Powers and Bohn-Konstantine Naryshkin (1.5) in the bottom section.

Justin Grimes (1064) over Ilya Abugov (1298) was the biggest upset of Round 2.  Others: Stephen Savage (1400) over Herbert Weisberg (1587), Siciliano (1344) over Gatumba Abu (1564), Lomer Cormier (1328) drawing Walter Champion (1668), and Bohn (1207) over John McLaughlin (1369).

Several Round 2 "jump-ins" swelled the field to 63 entrants -- 25 in the Open section, 23 in the middle group, and 15 in the U1400 section.


Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Alfred G Ward (1800) 		94.0 	Joseph F Kelly (1894) 
Steve Chen (1760) 		36.5 	Neil B Cousin (1833) 
Matthew Rothman (1779) 	29.0 	Niki Konovalchuk (1808) 
William Michael (1751) 	22.0 	Ames Abbot (1773) 


Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Douglas Thompson (1386) 	229.0 	John Minsk (1615) 
Gregor Siciliano (1344) 	220.0 	Gatumba Z Abu (1564) 
Stephen W Savage (1400) 	187.0 	Herbert Weisberg (1587) 
Lomer J Cormier (1328) 	170.0 	Walter Champion (1668) 
Menno G Koning (1513) 	77.5 	Alan P Beck (1668) 
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Justin P Grimes (1064) 	234.0 	Ilya Abugov (1298) 
Calvin F Bohn (1207) 		162.0 	JOHN MC LAUGHLIN (1369) 

Round 1 - August 6, 2002

The younger set has put on quite a show this summer, doing plenty of damage to both ratings and egos among the club’s veteran membership. The trend continued, too, in Round One of the August tournament. Middle schooler Chris Williams upset 1894-rated Joe Kelly in the Open section, while seventh-grader-to-be Steve Chen, following up on his outstanding performance in July, drew Rob Huntington (also rated 1894).  Meanwhile in the lower sections, Greg Siciliano and Calvin Bohn knocked off adult opponents.  And that’s just the tip of the iceberg.

Over the spring and summer as a whole, high school, middle school, and even elementary school players have turned in a series of impressive results.  Noah Pang actually won one Open section clear (ahead of masters Frank Sisto and John Curdo and expert Ed Epp), while fellow middle-schooler Niki Konovalchuk tied for first place with Curdo, Igor Foygel, and Robert Powell in another.

Kids have been even more prevalent in the middle and lower sections, with several of them  turning in impressive scores and/or pulling off major upsets.  But September is coming!  And while some of the stronger young players continue to compete during the school year, the numbers usually dwindle quite a bit when Tuesday becomes a "school night."  So another month or so and it should be easier on everyone’s ego!

As for the Round One results, Foygel and Curdo led a group of 10 players winning their initial tests in the 25-player Open section; Walter Champion and Mark Kaprielian headed a list of eight perfect scores in the 17-player U1750 section and John McLaughlin and Tom Powers topped seven competitors with 1.0 results in the 14-player U1400 section. That adds up to 56 entries, with more undoubtedly planning to jump in for Round 2.

Richard Albee (955) scored the biggest form reversal in Round One with a win over Ilya Abugov (1298)  -- a 343-point rating differential.  Greg Siciliano and Lomer Cormier shared top honors in the middle section with victories over George Goulding and John Minsk, respectively -- each with a 287-point differential.  Other upsets in that section: Ethan Thompson over Alan Beck (169 points) and Stephen Savage drawing  William Stein (131.5 points). There were no upsets meeting our 100-point criterion in the Open section.

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Christo Williams (1772) 	122.0 	Joseph F Kelly (1894) 
Steve Chen (1760) 	  67.0 	Rober Huntington (1894) 
Ames Abbot (1773) 	  63.0 	Robert L Harvey (1899) 
William Michael (1751) 	  41.0 	Neil B Cousin (1833) 
Name			 Pnts 	Victim 
Gregor Siciliano (1344) 	287.0 	George Goulding (1631) 
Lomer J Cormier (1328) 	287.0 	John Minsk (1615) 
Ethan Thompson (1499) 	169.0 	Alan P Beck (1668) 
Stephen W Savage (1400) 	131.5 	William F Stein (1663) 

Name			 Pnts 	Victim 
Richard Albee (955) 	343.0 	Ilya Abugov (1298)