MetroWest Chess Club - June Summer Swiss
June   3, 10, 17, 24   2003

Standings       Wall Chart       Pairings       Commentary        USCF X-table       Archive        Home
Tournament Commentary
written by Larry Eldridge
 

Round 4 - June 17, 2003

Igor Foygel and Chris Desmarais split top overall honors; Jim Todhunter was the Under 1750 winner with the tournament’s only 4-0 sweep, and 11-year-old Calvin Bohn took clear first place in the U1450 section.

Foygel and Desmarais each won two games and took a bye in Round 3. Expert Benjamin Goldberg, meanwhile, won three straight games to go into the last round as the clear leader in the Open section. But that put him up against Foygel in the last round (with the black pieces to boot), and the veteran senior master won their decisive game to leap frog past him. Meanwhile on Board 2, Desmarais defeated fellow master John Curdo to grab a share of the top spot with 3.5 points. Goldberg, expert Ed Epp, and A-players Noah Pang and Robert Powell finished in a four-way tie for third place with 3.0 each.

Todhunter won four straight games, clinching his triumph with a last-round victory over Mark Kaprielian on Board One. Kaprielian, Menno Koning, Matthew Phelps, and Edwin Burnett shared runner-up honors with 3.0 points each.

Bohn, who will be entering sixth grade next year, won his first three games to emerge as the sole U1450 leader going into the last round. He was paired against the highest-rated 2.5, Milton Academy professor and chess teacher David Smith, in the decisive game. Needing only a draw to clinch top honors, the youngster played sharply and accurately to achieve that result and a 3.5 final tally.

All the big upsets in the last round occurred in the middle section: Andrew Luff (1139) over Philip Mercurio (1660) -- a staggering 521-point rating difference, plus Jim Krycka (1305) over George Goulding (1634), and Douglas Thompson (1283) over Walter Champion (1612).

In U1450, : Matthew Perry (1048) defeated Fred L Harvey (1304), William Luff (1026) knocked off Andrew Taylor (1279),and Ken Moraff (1136) overcame Gregory Siciliano (1370).

The only Open section upset meeting our 100-point criterion was Noah Pang (1992) defeating Bijan Haririan (2109).

Round by Round Upsets: Round 4. mcc summer swiss: Open
Name Pnts Victim

Noah Pang (1992) 117.0 Bijan Haririan (2109)
Robert W Powell (1982)   24.0 Tomas P Girnius (2006)
Ames M Abbot (1752)    3.0 Gabriel Frieden (1758)

Round by Round Upsets: Round 4. mcc summer swiss: U1750
Name Pnts Victim
Andrew Luff (1139) 521.0 Philip Mercurio (1660)
James A Krycka (1305) 329.0 George Goulding (1634)
Douglas Thompson (1283) 329.0 Walter Champion (1612)
Edwin F Burnett (1533)   14.0 James H Rafferty (1547)

Round by Round Upsets: Round 4. mcc summer swiss: U1450
Name Pnts Victim
Matthew S Perry (1048) 256.0 Fred L Harvey (1304)
William Luff (1026) 253.0 Andrew Taylor (1279)
Ken Moraff (1136) 117.0 Gregory Siciliano (1370)
Calvin F Bohn (1241)   19.5 David M Smith (1280)

Round 3 - June 17, 2003

Expert Benjamin Goldberg has defeated veteran A-player Al Ward and fellow experts Noah Pang and Bijan Haririan in succession to post the only perfect 3.0 score heading into the last round and a decisive match up with top-seeded Igor Foygel.

Foygel and fellow masters Chris Desmarais and John Curdo are all a half-point off the pace with 2.5 scores-- the first two via a pair of wins and a third-round bye, Curdo with a first-round loss followed by two victories. Foygel gets the white pieces against Goldberg on Board One, while it’s Desmarais-Curdo on Board 2.

Goldberg, of course, is the only one of this quartet with "his fate in his own hands," so to speak, since he alone has a chance to clinch clear first place with a victory -- though defeating Foygel with the black pieces is a pretty tall order. A draw in this game or a win by Foygel would leave the winner on Board 2 (if there is one) tied for top honors.

Top-seeded Jim Todhunter and No. 3 Mark Kaprielian have the only perfect scores in the U1750 section and will meet on Board One in the finale, with Todhunter getting the white pieces.

Eleven-year-old Calvin Bohn has swept his first three games to hold clear first place in the U1450 section. He’ll face David Smith, the top-rated player with 2.5, on Board One, with Smith getting the white pieces.

Upsets: Gregory W Cermak (851) defeated Peter H Lee (1329); William Luff (1026) defeated Jason D. Krienke (1339); Raymond Salemi (1045) defeated Steven L Eddins (1332); Louis P Jacques (1400) Severine Wamala (1679); Eric Sonnenstuhl (1359) defeated George Goulding (1634); Joey Kagan (1544) defeated Philip Mercurio (1660); Harry Henriques (1462) defeated Edmund Staples (1568).

Round by Round Upsets: Round 3. mcc summer swiss: Open
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Benjami Goldberg (2019) 	90.0 	Bijan Haririan (2109) 
Neil B Cousin (1855) 		82.5 	Edward R Epp (2020) 
Randy Brueckner (1926)	82.0 	John Chamberlain (2008) 
Ames M Abbot (1752) 	12.0 	Larry Eldridge (1776) 

Round by Round Upsets: Round 3. mcc summer swiss: Open
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Louis P Jacques (1400) 	279.0 	Severine Wamala (1679) 
Eric Sonnenstuhl (1359) 	275.0 	George Goulding (1634) 
Joey Kagan (1544) 		116.0 	Philip Mercurio (1660) 
Harry Henriques (1462) 	106.0 	Edmund Staples (1568) 
Ethan Thompson (1490) 	  45.0 	Gatumba Z Abu (1580) 

Round by Round Upsets: Round 3. mcc summer swiss: Open
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Gregory W Cermak (851) 	478.0 	Peter H Lee (1329) 
William Luff (1026) 		313.0 	Jason D. Krienke (1339) 
Raymond Salemi (1045) 	287.0 	Steven L Eddins (1332) 
Andrew Taylor (1279) 		  92.0 	Scot Mc Laughlin (1371) 
John J Bottini (1231) 		  57.0 	Harvey G Reed (1345) 
Round 2 - June 10, 2003

The numbers keep turning out, with a record-tying 89 players competing in the June tournament so far: 26 in the Open section, 28 in U1750, and 35 in U1450.

Igor Foygel, Chris Desmarais, Bijan Haririan and Benjamin Goldberg share the lead at the halfway point with perfect 2.0 scores, with another quartet of John Curdo, Ed Epp, Derek Slater, and Neil Cousin breathing down their necks at 1.5. The top-seeded Foygel is taking a third-round bye, however, leading to a Board One pairing of Haririan - Desmarais, followed by Goldberg-Epp, Curdo-Slater, and John Chamberlain (the top-rated 1.0)-Cousin.

There’s also a four-way tie at 2.0 for the U1750 lead among Jim Todhunter, Mark Kaprielian, Matthew Phelps, and Ed Burnett. Meanwhile just two players are perfect in U1450 -- fifth-grader Calvin Bohn and 779-rated Patrick Cosentino, the latter via a first-round upset of Mary Murphy (1056) followed by the tournament’s biggest form reversal so far when he knocked off 1304-rated Fred Harvey.

The father-son team of Severine and Yowana Wamala scored two of the other major upsets to date: Severine (1643) defeating Robert Powell (1982) in Round One and 7-year-old Yowana (553) shocking Raymond Salemi (1045) in Round Two. Other notable surprise results: Trent Masiki (662) over Aaron Klein (1103); Plamen Krastev (1364) over Paul Vlahos (1542); Cousin (1855) holding Curdo (2206) to a draw; Calvin Hori over Jack Martin; Louis Jacques (1400) over Joey Kagan (1544); Tom Martin (1175) over Fred Harvey (1304); Phelps (1575) over Bill Michael (1700); Lanny Sun (1251) over Scott McLaughlin (1371); Andrew Taylor (1279) over John McLaughlin (1390); and John Bottini (1231) over Steven Eddins (1332).

Round by Round Upsets: Round 2. mcc summer swiss: Open
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Calvin G Hori (1678) 		169.0	John W Martin (1847)
Alfred G Ward (1800) 		  57.0	John Lanza (1857)

Round by Round Upsets: Round 2. mcc summer swiss: U1750
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Matthew W Phelps (1575) 	125.0 	William Michael (1700) 
James A Krycka (1305) 	  78.5 	Harry Henriques (1462) 
Peter J Karp (1574) 		  29.0 	David W Martin (1632) 
Lomer J Cormier (1511) 	  28.5 	Edmund Staples (1568) 
George Goulding (1634) 	  13.0 	Philip Mercurio (1660) 

Round by Round Upsets: Round 2. mcc summer swiss: U1450
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Patrick Cosentino (779) 	525.0 	Fred L Harvey (1304) 
Yowana R Wamala (553) 	492.0 	Raymond Salemi (1045) 
Trent Masiki (662) 		441.0 	Aaron Klein (1103) 
Thomas J Martin (1175) 	  97.5 	Gregory Siciliano (1370) 
Daniel Moraff (1246) 		  41.5 	Peter H Lee (1329) 
Calvin F Bohn (1241) 		  38.0 	Andrew Taylor (1279) 
William Luff (1026) 		  30.0 	Mary L Murphy (1056) 
Lanny Sun (1251) 		  14.5 	David M Smith (1280) 
 
Round 1 - June 3, 2003
 
Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Jacob K Wamala (1643) 	339.0 	Robert W Powell (1982) 
Neil B Cousin (1855) 		175.5 	John A Curdo (2206) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Plamen Krastev (1364) 	178.0 	Paul J Vlahos (1542) 
Louis P Jacques (1400) 	144.0 	Joey Kagan (1544) 
Matthew W Phelps (1575) 	85.0 	Philip Mercurio (1660) 
Peter J Karp (1574) 		30.0 	George Goulding (1634) 
James H Rafferty (1547) 	21.0 	Edmund Staples (1568) 

Name 			Pnts 	Victim 
Patrick Cosentino (779) 	277.0 	Mary L Murphy (1056) 
Thomas J Martin (1175) 	129.0 	Fred L Harvey (1304) 
Lanny Sun (1251) 		120.0 	Scot Mc Laughlin (1371) 
Andrew Taylor (1279) 		111.0 	John Mc Laughlin (1390) 
John J Bottini (1231) 		101.0 	Steven L Eddins (1332) 
Calvin F Bohn (1241) 		98.0 	Jason D. Krienke (1339) 
Sam A Giler (966) 		70.5 	Anabel Bacon (1107) 
Yowana R Wamala (553) 	54.5 	Trent Masiki (662) 
Daniel Moraff (1246) 		49.5 	Harvey G Reed (1345)